Public Outcry Grows Over Midtown South’s Historic Buildings Demolition Risk Amid Development Plans

Stakeholders expressed deep concerns at a recent public meeting regarding the potential demolition of historic buildings in Midtown South as the city pushes forward with its mixed-use development plan. The City Planning Commission (CPC) met to gather feedback on safeguards aimed at protecting these cultural landmarks amid the proposed zoning changes.

Community members highlighted the risk of losing historic structures to new development motivated by commercial interests. Testimonies detailed previous losses in the neighborhood, such as the former Hotel Pennsylvania and the Bankro Building, which have since become vacant lots. One resident emphasized the need for creative incentives to adapt and reuse existing buildings to prevent further blight and support environmental sustainability in the area.

Several speakers urged the commission to reconsider the proposed floor area ratio (FAR) increases, arguing that overly broad zoning changes could facilitate demolition rather than restoration. Recommendations included lowering the FAR and promoting the utilization of air rights from historic buildings to maintain the architectural integrity of the neighborhood while still addressing the housing crisis. Concerns also surfaced regarding the potential displacement of local businesses and residents if density increases are not carefully managed.

The commission acknowledged the necessity to preserve the neighborhood’s character while attempting to alleviate the housing shortage. Community organizations voiced their eagerness to work with planning authorities to ensure that historic preservation and new development efforts work hand-in-hand.

Notably, the Southeast Quadrant, which contains a high proportion of historic landmarks and a vibrant mixed-use fabric, was identified as requiring tailored zoning adjustments to protect these buildings. Testimonies raised questions about the impacts of the upzoning on properties that play a crucial role in the community’s historical narrative. The meeting’s attendees emphasized the significance of including robust protections against the demolition of these valuable structures.

Previous discussions in earlier meetings reinforced these concerns, with stakeholders reiterating the importance of a nuanced approach to accommodate both new housing and the preservation of historic sites (Source: https://youtu.be/P2KxZ_IezmY&t=15).

Moving forward, the CPC is expected to incorporate feedback from the meeting to refine the Midtown South plan, balancing housing demands with the imperative of preserving the neighborhood’s historical and cultural identity.